Showing posts with label Roundtable. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Roundtable. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Blogpoll Roundtable 4.whatever

The latest Blogpoll Roundtable is brought to us by the fine Virginia Tech blog, College Game Balls. Feel free to leave your answers in the comments.

1. By now everyone has heard that if there is a three way tie in the Big 12 South the highest ranked team in the BCS will play in the Big 12 Championship Game. That means the humans (66% of the BCS Poll) will determine the Big 12 South representative. Let’s assume Oklahoma sinks the pirate ship at home next week. Try to sway the pollsters by arguing which team you think should face off against the Big 12 North.

First off, I would encourage Missouri to forfeit their Big 12 North spot in the title game and let the second ranked team from the South have it. Because everyone wins if we do that. Nothing against Missouri, they are a fine team but if we could watch Oklahoma and Texas again I'm all in. I can't argue one above the other. Great quarterback? Check. Great line play on both sides of the ball? Check. Solid coaching? Check. Close loss on the road is your only blemish? Check (if Tech and Oklahoma is close). I probably like the Sooner defense over the other two, so that's your winner in my book.

2. ESPN is aggressively bidding on the rights to the BCS when Fox’s contract expires after the 2009 season. My half baked theory is if they do win the rights they will push for a +1 system. Lucrative television deals have landed ESPN in bed with each of the BCS conferences. The revenue a playoff would generate could be a huge motivator for the four letter to be the common denominator and unifier among the conferences that finally helps them all to see the light of why a playoff would be good for college football. Help expand upon or debunk this theory.

A plus one could pit #1 against #3 or #4. Like the question above, when they are so close do you really know who #1 and #2 are? That would be a step backwards. I think ESPN is good for college football, though. But if you are going to go playoff, go at least 16 teams, do home games for the higher seeds and get ESPN to pay all travel expenses or the NCAA. I mean, think about the payout for a BCS game, then think about the contract being for $125 million per year. A sixteen team playoff would be gold, Jerry. Schools shouldn't just be breaking even when they go to a big bowl. Make it work for the schools. A playoff system where schools meet at a neutral site sucks for the fans. Sure there's plenty of people that can afford that and are batshit crazy for college football. But the scene at a big home game is awesome and should be worked.

3. Rivalry week is around the corner. How do you think your team will fare? Feel free to talk a little or a lot of trash.

I think both teams will be way up for this game. It means something before it plays out on the field for the first time in a long time. It'll be Pat Whites last chance to audition for Cats.



So, I think we'll see a big night for him and big victory for West Virginia.

4. And now for a little fun… Assemble your dream announcing team. Pick a play-by-play announcer, color commentator, sideline reporter and for the hell of it celebrity guest that drops on by.

Brent Musburger, I like Kirk but I'm not going there. Color Guy-Lou Holtz. I'm serious, tell me he wouldn't make complete sense for five minutes, go off on a tangent for another five, give a motivational speech in between each, and then remind you that Notre Dame is one year away. And you, will think to yourself, "again?" Ray Lewis for sideline reporter. He would be awesome! Celebrity guest? Chris Farley should be the celebrity guest. It would really be awesome!

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Blogpoll Roundtable 4.5

The latest blogpoll roundtable is brought to us by Corn Blight from Corn Nation. For those unfamiliar, the blogpoll is the vision of Brian @ Mgoblog. He's kicked down the main stream media door to have the blogpoll right beside the AP and Coaches poll over at CBS Sports. As an aside, we have roundtable discussions from time to time to put our finger on the pulse of this great game we call college football. Keep an eye on that link to Corn Nation in the comments to see everyone's answers. On to the questions....

1. We’re about half way through the season. Has your team met your expectations, wildly exceeded them, or are you about to light the torches and storm your athletic department demanding blood?

Certainly, my expectations were much higher for West Virginia. I have to admit, that the final prediction I had of 11-2 is still very much possible. But the level of play, especially on offense, has been a disappointment. However, if you told me the defense would be holding opponents to 14.7 points a game I would have asked if I could have a sip of that cool-aid. So in a sense, my expectations have been exceeded and unrealized. Still, the team is undefeated in conference and has just as good a shot as anyone to win the Big East.

2. In an election year, all sorts of promises will be made, few will be kept. What is one promise or item you thought you could count on that hasn’t come to pass yet this season? Is there still a chance?

The promise to attack the middle of the field in the passing game and not a gazillion bubble screens was the promise that excited me the most. It represented an addition to the offense that would seemingly make it more potent. But we aren't passing over the middle, we're bubble screening the shit out of people but not in a good way, and the running game isn't OMG! great this year.

3. Georgia #1... No, USC #1.… No, Oklahoma #1.… No, Texas #1! Who’s the real #1 team, and who do you think will make it to the big BCS National Title game?

A question like this tends to make me think about each teams schedule down the stretch, and that Oklahoma or Texas won't play in the Big 12 championship and we know how that worked out for Georgia last year. But it could very well be that #1 and #2 at the end of the year will both play in the Big 12 south. That's not to take anything away from any of the other teams, but if they end up #1 & #2 are you willing to watch that as your title game? I wouldn't complain because you know it will be a great game. But the Big East has no dog in that fight, so don't pay attention to me. The great thing is that most of those teams have a challenging game this weekend. A thinning of the herd is right around the corner.

4. In only a few weeks, college football fans get to be treated with the obligatory and annual “We Need a Playoff” screaming. Well, you don’t get a playoff, but I’ll let you make one change to the BCS (and no, you can’t cop out and have the BCS commit suicide) to make the world a better place. What is your change?

Add the blogpoll to the point system!!! I don't think I'm great at rankings, but records and margin of victory don't matter as much to me as what I'm able to watch, and given my position here and at AOL I'm exposed to the entire country. We have the advantage of covering our favorite team as little or as much as we want. Unlike reporters that have to report extensively on their beat, we're free to switch between as many games as the coax allows. We also hold grudges and we're biased. But it's one of the few things I put up every single week. I take pride in it and I know the majority of the blogpoll voters do as well. We tell dick jokes and make fun of team x, but this is something I think we as a group are just as capable as anyone else in the equation.

5. Using this year ONLY - no historical references - respond to the statement “The Big 12 is a better conference than the SEC”. There’s nothing sillier than conference wars, but then again, there’s nothing sillier than how SEC fans respond to any challenge to their supremacy. Aim, Fire!

The Big 12 has a historic supply of great quarterbacks this year. Oklahoma St. is the big surprise, but Alabama is the big surprise in the SEC. We thought they would be good, but not like that, Poppy! Top to bottom, I don't see either being measurably better. That's a victory for the Big 12 in a sense. But I can't put the Big 12 past the SEC, because there is defense to go around. Mississippi St. and South Carolina are both top tier defenses and those aren't exactly the big boys of the conference. Oh yeah, Tennessee is like 14th in total D.

Monday, September 08, 2008

Blogpoll Roundtable 4.2

Brought to us by the fine Georgia blog, Braves & Birds. He asks the questions, and we answer. It's like Fox News, but better.

Your college football program wants to know how you, its valued customer, thinks of your consumer experience! Please help your program evaluate its performance in the first two weeks of the season! Can you feel the West Virginia difference!?!

1. How would you rate your program's service to you in the first two weeks of the season?

To the right is my customer service rep. He warmed me up with a lot of promising deals, but what I got so far is a lot of talk and not much action.

It's a low feeling. Probably worse than if we would have been predicted to finish in the middle of the Big East. I have no problem with kids being young on defense and making the occasional mistake. But I haven't seen any fire in anyone's eyes on defense, and that is just inexcusable. I like to be nice, and I like to tip. But you gotta earn it at some point, and I just haven't seen anything worthy of it yet.

2. How happy are you with your program's overall scheme? We are in a period in which the spread has become a total obsession in the media. If you're a fan of a spread team, are you happy with the way your program has implemented it? If you're a fan of a non-spread team, do you wish that your program would convert to this Xenu of offenses?

Since we were built around running the spread, I think it would be a great idea to use it. What I've seen has nothing more than formation to do with the spread. It might very well be that there isn't anyone to fill the role of Owen Schmitt, and that has changed everything. He was always that third option that people had to watch for out of the backfield and he threw great lead blocks. Our offensive line isn't built to hold off defenders in obvious passing situations. It's built to beat the defenders to the point of attack and to create running lanes through zone blocking. But it doesn't seem that we are using that advantage. I love Noel Devine, but he doesn't scare too many people as an up the middle runner. Until someone gives us that, I expect more of the same.

3. Rate your stadium's cleanliness and menu options.

Oh please! It's not a dirty stadium at all, but the food choices suck. I know high schools that have better menus.

4. As an incentive to provide your valued feedback, you will be entered into a drawing for exciting prizes! What one prize would you like for your program?

Terence Kerns to get with it and help this team out. I understand that he is pretty much a red shirt this year, but he could have filled the void left by Schmitt and given teams a lot to worry about coming out of the backfield. It will be a must to have him in the backfield next year.

5. Since we're all about choices, take one of the following two options for entertainment's sake:

a. What's your most memorable experience involving a comment card?

b. If your program were a casual dining chain, which one would
it be? Yes, this is a tricky question because the defining characteristic of a casual dining chain is its sameness. No one said this Roundtable would be easy. Bonus points if you can make a compelling case that your program is Chotchkie's or Flingers.


Chotchkie's- I mean, the boss is all like "I'm not going to yell at you, but you need to wear more flare." Meaning, I'm not mad at you, son. I know you wanted to tackle that guy but he was really trying hard and that made you nervous. What I want you to do is, I want you to do your best. And if you get beat, you just have to try again. I mean, Rome wasn't built in a day. Keep your chin up, because I love you!

Monday, September 17, 2007

Blogpoll Roundtable 3.2

We were thinking that just about everyone we know has dressed up like a Pirate at one point or another. So we thought that maybe we didn't actually have to show them dressed up like a Pirate to work them into Pirate Week. I mean really, is anyone going to argue that the lovely Janet, here on the left wouldn't look smashing in a Pirate outfit? Yeah, we though so too!

OK, now that you have stopped cursing the day the scarf was invented we can move on to the Blogpoll Roundtable brought to us by Peter over at Burnt Orange Nation. In this roundtable we'll look at some of the stories that are starting to develop around the college football world.


1. Handicap your team's chances to win your conference championship. If your team is not the favorite, who is?

With Louisville's loss to Kentucky, I say we have a great chance to take the Big East. Not that that counts toward their conference record, but the Cardinal defense has been offensive the first three weeks against two lesser opponents and KY. And if they don't fix it soon, I think USF and Rutgers have a good chance of beating Louisville. South Florida has won, but the offense has not been what I was expecting so far. I think the game at South Florida will be a big test, but I also think West Virginia will be at full strength this time around. I have no idea what to think of Rutgers until they play someone, but they haven't beaten WVU since I was in high school, so I like our chances. And Cincinnati is making some people take notice this year. Will they still be as strong at the end of the year?

The Big East is a young conference, so I can do a little math without digging too deep. West Virginia is 1-1 against USF and UL, and 13-2 against Cincinnati and 28-4-2 against Rutgers. Soooooo, (.5+.5+.86+.82)/4= 67% chance we win.


2. Outline the (realistic) best case and worst case scenarios for your team.

Best case scenario for West Virginia would be that they would be the only undefeated team in the country at the end of the year. Otherwise, I do believe a one loss SEC/Pac 10 team would get the nod in a championship game. And yeah, the defense would miraculously turn it around and become a strength.

Worst Case would be that we lose to Rutgers, South Florida, and Louisville and play Western Michigan in a bowl game. Seriously, if Slaton or White were to get injured, I think we have the backups to keep the offense moving. But if we have a bunch of injuries on the defensive line, we are screwed.

3. We're only three games in to the season, but teams and storylines are starting to take shape. Compare your team to a character or theme from a fable or children's tale.

Hmmmm, Fables of the Reconstruction by REM comes to mind. Sorry, but I can't help it. The defense has been under construction for two years now. I liken it to the San Diego Charger teams of the 80's that had all the firepower on offense and no defense. It was only good enough to get them to the AFC championship game, but never the Super Bowl (I know the Chargers went in 94, I'm just talking about the 80's). And that is where WVU is going to be until they become a complete team with a formidable defense.

4. Imagine you're the coach of your team. Give three specific changes you'd implement immediately which you think would have the biggest impact on improving the team.

I'm purposely not going to talk about the defense here.

1) Option off of Owen Schmitt on first down. Everyone is so keyed in on Slaton that it almost hurts to see him get bottled up on first downs that go for nothing.

2) Crossing paterns! I know they exist, I see other teams use them against us. NO MORE WR SCREENS. Well, I'll limit the wr screens to two per game, but that's it!

3) No more directional kicking on kickoffs. I think WV leads the nation in kicking off out of bounds. Kick it to one of the up backs and be done with it.

5. USC, LSU/Florida, and Oklahoma have established themselves as the frontrunners in the early going. Which other team or teams are you eyeballing as potential BCS party crashers?

I like Oregon or Cal from the Pac 10. Maybe Ohio St. Possibly BC. WVU and Rutgers as well. A lot of strange things would have to happen for any of the above, but this is college football we are talking about.